ForcedFromExecutivePaytoHourlyWageNewYorkTimes
MarkCooperstartedhisworkdayonarecentmorningcleaningthedoorhandlesofanofficebuildingwitharag,vigorouslyshakingoutarugatabackentranceandpushing
adustmopdownalonghallway。
NinemonthsagohelosthisjobasthesecuritymanagerforthewesternUnitedStatesforaFortune500pany,overseeingabudgetof$1.2millionandearningabout$70,000
ayear.Nowheisgratefulforthe$12anhourhemakesinwhatisknowninunemploymentcirclesasasurvivaljobatafriendsjanitorialservicespany.Butthatdoesnotmaketheworkanyeasier。
Yourefightingdespair,discouragement,depressioneveryday,Mr.Coopersaid。
Workingfivedaysaweek,9a.m.to6p.m.,Mr.Cooperisnotcountedbytraditionalmeasuresasamongtherecessionscasualtiesatthispoint.Buthistumbledowntheeconomicladderisamongthemoredisquietingandoftenhiddenaspectsofthedownturn。
ItisnotclearhowmanyprofessionalslikeMr.Cooperhetakenonthesetypesoflower-payingjobs,whicharethemselvesinshortsupply.Manyaredoingtheirbesttoholdoutaslongaspossibleonunemploymentbenefitsandsingswhilestilllookingforworkin
theirfields。
About1.7millionpeople,however,wereworkingpart-timeinJanuarybecausetheycouldnotfindfull-timework,a40percentjumpfromDecember2007,whentherecessionbegan,accordingtotheBureauofLaborStatistics。
Andexpertsagreethatastheeconomicdownturncontinuesandasmorepeoplebegintoexhausttheirjoblessbenefitsandotheroptions,thesituationMr.Cooperisinwill
inevitablybeemoremon。
Interviewswithmorethantwodozenlaid-offprofessionalsacrossthecountry,includingarchitects,formersalesmanagersandexecutiveswhohetakenonlower-paying,stop-gapjobstohelpmakeendsmeet,foundthattheywereworkingforplaceslikeU.P.S.,aVerizonWirelesscallcenterandaliquorstore.Formanyoftheworkers,thepsychological
adjustmentwasjustasdifficultasthefinancialone,withtheirsenseofidentityandself-worthupended。
Ithasbeenlikepeelingbackthelayersofabadonion,saidAmeArlt,53,whorecentlyacceptedapositionasacustomer-servicerepresentativeatanonlineinsurance-leadsreferralserviceinFranklin,Tenn.,after20yearsofworkinginexecutivejobs.Witheverylayeryoupeelback,youdiscoversomethingelseaboutyourself.Youheto
makeanadjustment。
Somepeoplehadexhaustedtheirjoblessbenefits,orwereineligible;otherssaiditwasimpossibleforthemtoliveontheirunemploymentchecksalone,orsaiditwasamatterof
pride,orsanity,thatdrovethemtofindajob,anyjob。
Injustoneillustrationofthedemandforlow-wagework,aspokesmanforU.P.S.saidthepanysawthenumberofapplicantsthislastholidayseasonforjobssortinganddeliveringpackagesalmosttripleto1.4million
fromthe500,000itnormallyreceives。
WhenMs.Arltappliedforthejob,shesentinastripped-downrsumthathidher20-yearcareeratnationalmediapanies,duringwhichsheascendedtovicepresidentofbranddevelopmentattheOnmandVideoCorporationandwasmaking$165,000
ayear.Shedecidedin2001tostartherownbusiness,openinganequestrianstoreandthenfoundingamagazinedevotedtothesport.Butwiththeeconomyslowing,shewas
forcedtoshutterbothbusinessesbyJuneoflastyear。
Afterapplyingformorethan100jobs,mostlydirector-levelandaboveinmarketingandbranding,andgettingjusttwointerviews,Ms.Arltsaidsherealizedlastfallthatshehadtodosomethingtoclosethemonthlyfinancial
hemorrhage。
HernewjobatHometownQuotespays$10to$15anhourandhasmostlyentaileddataentry.Buteventhoughshehaspartedwayswithsomefriendsbecausesheisnolonger
intheirsocialstratum,Ms.Arltsaidshewasgladshewasnolongersittingathome,thinking,WhoheInotheardfromtoday?
Hernewpaycheckcovershermortgagebutnotherotherlivingexpenses.Recently,shecashedoutwhatwasleftofherretirementportfolio,about$17,000。
Ithasbeenthehardestthinginmylife,shesaid.Ithasbeenharderthanmydivorcefrommyhusband.Ithasreallybeenevenworsethanthedeathofmymother。
Nearlyallofthoseinterviewedsaidtheyconsideredtheirsituationstemporaryandplannedtoresumetheircareerswheretheyleftoffoncetheeconomyimproves.Butthereare
peoplelikeJohnEller,51,ofLeesSummit,Mo.,whoofferaglimpseofhowdifficultitcanbetobounceback。
Mr.EllerhadbeenaseniordirectoratSprint,earningasmuchas$150,000ayearandoverseeing7,000employeesat13callcenters,beforebeinglaidoffin2002amid
theeconomiccontractionaftertheSept.11terroristattacks。
Ayearlater,hefoundanotherjob,atroughlyhalfthepay,managingacallcenterinNewJersey.Afterhelostthatjobtwoyearslaterinadownsizing,
Mr.EllerfoundhimselfoutofworkforanotheryearbeforelandingacontractpositionrunningtwocallcentersinKansasandIllinois,earningclosetosixfigures。
Butafterthatendedayearlater,hewasunabletofindworkforseveralmonths.InJuly2007,hetookwhathethoughtwouldbeatemporaryjobfor$10anhourasabakerin
agrocerystore.HewaslaidoffagainlastOctober。
Mr.Ellerquicklylandedanewsurvivaljob,workingasasupervisorontheovernightshiftforacontractorprocessingimmigrationapplicationsforthefederalgovernmentat
asalaryofabout$34,000ayear.Butwitheightchildrenandawifetosupport,Mr.Ellersaidhewasstillbelowpovertylevel。Thefamilyhasnotbeenabletomakemortgage
paymentsinfivemonthsandhasbeenonthebrinkofforeclosure。
Imstillscratchingandclawingandtryingtoworkmywayback,hesaid。
InMr.Cooperscase,relyingonunemploymentcheckswasneveraseriousconsideration.ThemaximumbenefitthatjoblesspeoplecancollectinArizonais$240aweek,
amongthelowestinthecountryandmuchlessthanisrequiredtocoverthemortgageonthefortablefour-bedroomhomeinGlendalethatheandhiswife,MaggieMacias-Cooper,share。
Mrs.Macias-Cooper,whoworksasapersonaltrainerinagymbuiltinwhatusedtobethecouplesthree-cargarage,hasseenherclientbaseshrinkto10fromabout50overthelastyear。
InadditiontogivingMr.Cooperajobasajanitor,hisfriendagreedtopayforthecouplesbenefitsthroughCobra.MaintaininghealthcarecoveragewasparamountforthefamilybecauseMrs.Macias-Cooperrecentlyhadbreastcancer。
Someunemployedprofessionalssaidtheydecidednottoseekevenpart-timeworkbecauseitmightinterferewiththeirjobsearches.ButMr.Cooperriseseverydayat4a.m.and,afteratimeofprayer,devotestwohourstohisjobhuntontheputer.
Heprintsoutadetailedcalllistofprospectiveemployerstotakewithhim,squeezinginphoneconversationsduringbreaksthroughoutthedayfromhispickuptruck,
whichhecallshisoffice。
ThereweretimesIbrokedown,Mr.Coopersaid.Ibrokedownthinking,ThisiswhatIvebee.
ButMrs.Macias-Cooper,whoadmittedthatshewasinitiallyembarrassedaboutherhusbandsnewjob,sayssheisnowgrateful。
Thereisnoshame,saidMrs.Macias-Cooper,whogrewtearyduringaninterviewattheirhome.Iamveryproudofmyhusbandthathewillgotoanylengths,dowhateverittakes,tokeephisfamilyafloat,
ifitmeansmoppingfloors,cleaningurinals。